Judging Sethe
When Morrison finally reveals the circumstances that caused the isolation and haunting of 124, characters and readers alike are forced to grapple with Sethe’s divisive decision and ultimately formulate an opinion on the morality of her actions. Readers, being so far removed from the circumstances of the event, are unable to pass judgement on the matter because they do not have the lived experience necessary to comprehend the rationale behind Sethe’s decision. Therefore, the diversity of opinions displayed by various characters helps readers understand a variety of complex perspectives from figures who lived through slavery and are (more) qualified to pass judgement. One of the first reactions we see is from Denver. Sethe does not voluntarily reveal the circumstances of Beloved’s death, which causes Denver to stumble upon the story abruptly. Because she was only a newborn at the time of the events and subsequently lived in relative isolation, she could not find out about the trag...